Park Avenue Paninoteca
Rochester, NY · Since 2014

Where American Flair
Meets Italian Finesse

Honest, soul-satisfying cuisine crafted from family recipes passed down through generations. Every panini carries a piece of our story.

Make a Reservation →Find Us
Location
230 Monroe Ave, Rochester
Open Today
11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Reservations
585 270 5601
Scroll
Handcrafted Paninis Authentic Italian Pasta Family Recipes Made With Love A Taste of Italy in Rochester Handcrafted Paninis Authentic Italian Pasta Family Recipes Made With Love A Taste of Italy in Rochester
Freshly made Italian panini
2014
The Inception
Our Story

A Family Affair in the
Heart of Rochester

Back in 2014, armed with family recipes passed down through generations, we opened our doors to welcome fellow food enthusiasts. The idea was simple — to serve honest, soul-satisfying Italian cuisine that feels like a warm embrace.

Our tale begins with a passionate duo — yours truly and my father-in-law, who happened to be Italian.

We started as a cozy hidden gem and gradually evolved into a community hub where friends gather and families celebrate milestones over plates of delectable paninis.

Visit Us Today
Why Park Ave

From Panini Dreams
to Reality

Park Avenue Paninoteca isn't just a restaurant; it's a dream woven into the fabric of the community. The warmth you feel when you step in is the echo of conversations and laughter since day one.

Crafted With Care

Each panini is handcrafted, carrying a piece of our story in every single bite.

Authentic Recipes

Family recipes passed down through generations, straight from the heart of Italy.

Community Hub

A space where friends gather and families celebrate the milestones that matter.

Savor the Fusion

American flair meets Italian finesse — every bite a journey to the heart of flavors.

Loved By The Neighborhood

What Our Guests
Are Saying

Real words from real regulars — the warmth you feel when you step in is the echo of these conversations.

“

I don't know how I haven't been here before now! Best panini I've ever had for sure. I got the Vincenzo which seems to be a special that never leaves. This will be a new staple place for me without question!

A
Aaron J.
Rochester, NY
“

A recommendation from two locals said it would be the best food we'd ever had… they were NOT wrong. Chicken quesadilla, chicken cutlet panini, burger, and the cheesecake — all absolutely delicious. I have never had a better panini in my life.

Y
Yaritza C.
Visitor
“

I had the Vincenzo Panino and it was amazing. One of the best chicken sandwiches I've ever had. I highly recommend this place.

N
Neil A.
Rochester, NY
“

A true hidden gem on Monroe Ave. Everything tastes like it was made with love — because it is. The lasagna and the tiramisu are worth the trip alone. It feels like being welcomed into someone's family kitchen.

M
Maria L.
Brighton, NY
“

Authentic Italian done right. The arancini and gnocchi took me straight back to Italy, and the staff treats you like a regular from your very first visit. This is now our go-to spot for date night.

D
David R.
Rochester, NY
“

Cozy, warm and endlessly delicious. We came for lunch and ended up planning to come back for dinner the same week. The paninis are pressed to perfection and the minestrone is pure comfort in a bowl.

S
Sofia B.
Irondequoit, NY
10+
Years Serving Rochester
100%
Family Recipes
∞
Warm Welcomes
1
Neighborhood Hub
Plan Your Visit

Your Gateway to
American-Italian Delights

Conveniently located at 230 Monroe Ave — we bring you a seamless blend of flavors, warmth and ease.

Operating Hours

Monday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Get In Touch

Make a Reservation
Good to Know

Frequently Asked
Questions

Everything you need before you drop by. Still curious? Give us a call — we'd love to chat.

Call Us
01What are you known for?
LasagnaCapreseGrilled ChickenBar FoodFrench FriesQuesadillasMinestrone SoupSandwichesChocolate Chip CookieSaladsCaponataAranciniCannoliMeatballsCaesar SaladCheesecakeVegetarian FoodGerman Potato SaladCateringFast FoodGnocchiDessertTiramisuPastaPaniniPasta SaladFriesDeli SandwichesMinestroneSoupPie
02What meals do you serve?
We serve Lunch and Dinner — open daily from 11:00 AM.
03Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes — we offer both Delivery and Takeout. Call us to place your order.
04Where are you located?
We are located in Rochester, NY at 230 Monroe Ave. Get directions →
05What areas do you serve?
We proudly serve: Rochester, Brighton, Arnett, Otis, Central Business District, Southwedge, Neighborhood Of The Arts, Westfall, Highland Park, Irondequoit, Park Meigs, S. Marketview Heights, Crittenden, Park Central, Conea, N. Marketview Heights, Plymouth-exchange, Beechwood, Ridgeland, and Wadsworth Square.

Come Savor the Essence of Italy

Take a sneak peek into what makes us your go-to spot for a delicious rendezvous with American-Italian cuisine — right here in Rochester.

Get Directions →